CLE123, Inc.
Continuing Legal Education made as EASY as 1 2 3!
Call us at (866) 925-3123
Customer Support Available 8am-8pm EST
Courses
- Courses
- Supreme Court - Scott v. Harris (High Speed Police Chases)
Supreme Court - Scott v. Harris (High Speed Police Chases)
- Sku:
- OYZ009
- Price:
- US$50.00
- Total Time:
- 74
- Credits:
- Select State to Find Out
Course Description
Facts of the Case
After a police officer attempted to pull him over for speeding, Victor Harris fled in his vehicle, initiating a high-speed car chase. Attempting to end the chase, Deputy Timothy Scott rammed Harris's vehicle with his police cruiser. Harris crashed and was rendered a quadriplegic. Harris sued Scott in federal District Court, alleging that Scott had violated his Fourth Amendment rights by using excessive force. Scott claimed qualified immunity as a government official acting in his official capacity, but the District Court rejected the claim. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed.
In order to show that a government official is not entitled to qualified immunity, a plaintiff is required to prove that the official violated a clearly established constitutional right. The Eleventh Circuit ruled that Scott's actions constituted an unreasonable seizure in violation of the Fourth Amendment. Because there was no imminent threat - Harris remained in control of his vehicle and the roads were relatively empty - Scott's use of deadly force was unconstitutional. Although no Appellate Court had ruled on the specific question of the use of deadly force in a high-speed chase, the Eleventh Circuit ruled that the limits on deadly force were "clearly established."
Question
1) Does a police officer who stops a high-speed chase by ramming a fleeing suspect's car violate the Fourth Amendment's protection against unreasonable seizure?
2) Was it "clearly established" in federal law that an officer violates the Fourth Amendment by using deadly force during a high-speed chase?
About the Lecturer
Course Audio Files
Please Login To Listen
Registration is quick and free and gives you access to listen to hundreds of audio files
Course Notes
Please Login To View
Registration is quick and free and gives you access to all of the class notes